5% off $500+
use code 500SALE
on orders of $149+
🟥🟧🟨 SAVE 40% on COLORMATES 🟩🟦🟪
use code: CREATE40 (excludes Colormates Smooth & Silky)
Buyer Rewards
save on every order
reseller, 501c, military

Contact Us

Talk to Live and Genuine People, Ready to Help.

The Paper Mill Store makes it easy to get in touch. On this page, you can find information about our locations and contact information, including our phone number, email address and hours. We have customer service specialists on standby to answer your questions Monday through Friday, from 7:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Central Time. Our friendly and knowledgeable experts are happy to help via phone or email. We're also happy to chat with you about our custom finishing services, competitive pricing, free shipping and rewards program.

You can reach our customer service team Monday thru Friday, 7:30am to 5:00pm, Central Time.
See holiday hours

Phone: (800) 790-TPMS (8767)
Email: cs@thepapermillstore.com

Live Chat: Ask us a question


The Paper Mill Store .com
Sun Prairie, WI 53590

Shipping and Returns
The Paper Mill Store .com
2323 Venture Court
Neenah, WI 54956

Holiday Hours:

Christmas Day Monday December 25, 2023 Closed
New Years Day Monday January 1, 2024 Closed
Memorial Day Monday May 27, 2024 Closed
Independence Day Thursday

July, 4 2024

July, 5 2024

Labor Day Monday September 2, 2024 Closed
Thanksgiving Thursday

November 28, 2024

November 29, 2024

Christmas Day Wednesday December 25, 2024 Closed
New Years Day Wednesday January 1, 2025 Closed